Saturday, December 2, 2023
HomeBonsaiRy2Tree2 Bonsai Weblog: Bonsai Seed Myths

Ry2Tree2 Bonsai Weblog: Bonsai Seed Myths

          For folks new to the artwork of bonsai, the thought of rising your individual bonsai tree from seed is commonly irresistible. In idea, rising a bonsai from seed could be a rewarding journey that permits you to give delivery to your individual perfect picture of what a bonsai ought to be, however sadly, in apply, seed-growing is a journey which is fraught with frustration for the overwhelming majority of rookies. It has been stated that it takes 10 years of expertise in bonsai earlier than you perceive the way to develop from seed effectively. I share this to not discourage you, however to brace you for the problem forward. In the event you’re a brand new reader, I might encourage you to take a look at the primary submit on this rising from seed sequence, “The Root of All Bonsai.” In that earlier submit, we talked in regards to the varied alternative routes to begin your bonsai and the benefits and drawbacks of every technique. Nevertheless, in case you are dead-set on rising from seed, you are in luck! Drawing by myself 15 years of bonsai expertise and the 60+ years of expertise of my bonsai instructor Dan Robinson, in the present day we’ll lower by way of the BS and dispel widespread myths about rising bonsai from seed earlier than we proceed to investigate the important ideas that may enable you notice your bonsai-from-seed goals within the subsequent weeks. 

         In the event you’re seeking to purchase seeds for bonsai – full disclosure – I’m penning this sequence with the intent to promote my very own seeds for rising bonsai (see right here). On the threat of sounding too sales-pitchy, I’m sending an unique hard-copy model of this weblog sequence to all my clients. The hard-copy information will merely information you thru the sophisticated 10+yr problem of rising bonsai from seed. If you cannot watch for our weekly launch of future weblog articles on this sequence, you’ll obtain the complete information immediately along with your buy of seeds. Thanks prematurely for supporting my bonsai work!


Keep tuned to this sequence to learn to remodel these…

Left a Japanese black pine, and proper a European beech. Each 2-3 years previous. 

…into this!

A 50-year-old Japanese black pine, grown from seed by Dan Robinson and now on show at Elandan Gardens.

          Skilled bonsai artists are amazed on the enthusiasm of rookies in search of to develop from seed, however we all know a grim fact. Sadly, most “bonsai seed kits” prey on the ignorance of those enthusiastic would-be-bonsai hobbyists for a fast buck. “Bonsai seed kits” usually quantity to little greater than a rip-off for rookies as a result of the kits do nothing to show the proprietor how to achieve success bonsai growers, a lot much less artists. Many rookies get so discouraged by their withering seedlings that they provide up on bonsai all collectively. 

          Rising a bonsai from seed is certainly more durable than conserving a bonsai alive that has already been grown. So in case you are eager about gifting a bonsai novice one thing which you hope will get them into the pastime, I counsel a younger, established bonsai as a substitute (and embody a bonsai guide for them to refer to simply!). By taking this route, the tree is extra prone to survive longer and can enable your reward recipient to find out about and apply bonsai strategies way more totally than they’d by solely rising from seed. I usually counsel a beginner-friendly tropical species like jade or ficus for indoor rising or elm or maple for outside rising. Nevertheless, in case you intend to purchase seeds as a present for somebody who’s already into the artwork of bonsai, that could possibly be a greater match than somebody who has zero bonsai expertise.

That is an instance of a typical bonsai seed package. One challenge I take with these kits is that the bonsai timber they use to promote had been positively not grown from a package like this. It is virtually false promoting. In the event you hold your seedling within the pot they supply, not in your complete lifetime would you see your seedlings change into the tree within the picture. Solely with extra superior bonsai information, like what I goal to share on this sequence, can your seedlings get to that degree, however the potential is certainly there.

2B. “Bonsai seeds are uncommon.”

          One fantasy that makes “bonsai seed kits” appear particular is the concept that there’s such a factor as a “bonsai seed” within the first place. The truth is, there aren’t any magic beans for bonsai timber; bonsai timber usually are not genetically totally different from their full-sized counterparts, and neither are their seeds. The seeds from a one-foot-tall ponderosa pine bonsai will nonetheless produce a 100+ foot tree if planted in the proper place. Pure and man-made bonsai are as a substitute small as a result of constrictions on the amount their roots can fill in addition to because of common pruning.

          So no, the seeds I or another “bonsai seed” vendor has usually are not that particular. The one sense that they might be particular is that I’ve picked a species that may survive and develop simply in bonsai tradition. Some species of timber are definitely extra confirmed of their means to change into lovely bonsai than different species, but it surely’s positively price experimenting with new species! In the event you can determine the proper time to gather mature seeds, you possibly can work on beginning your individual bonsai with out shopping for seeds from myself or any bonsai seed package!

Take this apple for instance. in case you eat these apples and plant their seeds, although this tree is a bonsai, the seeds will develop to full-size apple timber if the seeds are planted within the floor and left unchecked.
Bonus enjoyable reality: Leaves might get smaller when a tree turns into a mature bonsai, however fruits and flowers will keep the identical dimension for any given species.

2C. “All bonsai are grown from seed.”

          On its floor, this looks as if an apparent reality that each one timber come from seed, however in actuality, that isn’t so! {Many professional} bonsai artists (together with lots of the greatest Japanese artists) won’t ever even contact seed-growing of their whole bonsai profession! There are a number of different sources of fabric to begin your bonsai all with their very own benefits and drawbacks. This was the subject of our first submit on this sequence “The Root of All Bonsai,” so learn there if you wish to overview the options. Typically occasions bonsai artists discover different vegetation in nature, landscapes, or nurseries which we then convert into bonsai.

2D. “Rising bonsai from seed is one of the simplest ways to find out about bonsai.”

          That is additionally a subject that I mentioned at size in our earlier submit, “The Root of All Bonsai,” but it surely bears repeating. Bonsai Rising (like from seed) makes use of fairly totally different strategies than Bonsai Styling (like when remodeling a bush right into a bonsai). I am making an attempt to make use of these two phrases to tell apart the ability units as a result of in some methods they’re very totally different. Bonsai Rising is concentrated on creating and framing the trunk and first branches of your bonsai because the thickness and traits of age on these options will change solely very slowly as soon as the tree is in a small bonsai pot. Bonsai Styling, nonetheless, is a ability set for arranging the branches and foliage in addition to carving deadwood on a tree when you’re already completely satisfied along with your trunk and main branches. These aren’t completely mutually unique expertise, although. For instance, you could have some bonsai at residence which you beforehand styled however now are pondering that you desire to their trunks or branches to be thicker. Strategies from Bonsai Rising could be utilized to vegetation in a bonsai pot which you want to add thickness, but it surely is not going to be as speedy of a change as if the tree was nonetheless rising in a big coaching pot or rising within the floor (extra on this in our long-term planning article).

2E“The extra I prune, the sooner my bonsai will develop.”

          Many bonsai novices assume that pruning by some means stimulates the tree to mature sooner. In some methods, this has fact; pruning often promotes the manufacturing of dense tremendous branching – it is a method that can be utilized for Bonsai Styling on extra mature timber when the tree’s trunk dimension is usually fastened. Nevertheless, there’s a easy purpose why this doesn’t end in elevated trunk dimension. Constructing a trunk is an costly course of, each by way of sugars wanted and vitality. All people already is aware of bonsai timber – like all vegetation – depend on their leaves and foliage to provide sugar for all their capabilities, so it’s the solely logical extension that to attain the quickest velocity of trunk progress, one would need to have as many leaves and needles as attainable. The extra photo voltaic panels in your bonsai energy plant, the sooner it is going to make investments its vitality into constructing the trunk you need to construct a greater bonsai on high of. The thought of strategic pruning and strategic absence of pruning may also be reiterated in additional element in our future posts relating to the long-term progress plans for our seeds.

Word that these trident maple prebonsai have been allowed to develop 6-7 toes tall sacrifice branches to assist thicken their trunks. These timber are in all probability round 5 years previous.

2F“Rising from seed is a waste of time, I will by no means dwell to see it mine change into a great bonsai!”

          I do know I’ve spent numerous time on this article and in final week’s article speaking about how time-consuming rising from seed and the way rookies might need to rethink this path as your start line in bonsai. That stated, I do not need you to assume that it is a waste of time! I am right here to assist taper your expectations and plan for actuality. Rising from seed is certainly time-consuming, however whether or not or not you survive to see the tree change into an award-winning specimen doesn’t should affect whether or not or not you’ll benefit from the course of! There’s additionally a sure magnificence within the thought of making a residing piece of artwork that you’ll go on to the subsequent era of bonsai artists! That stated, even in case you solely need to make investments your time in tasks for which you will note returns in your lifetime, I need to emphasize that utilizing the proper strategies, we are able to considerably lower down the time that it takes for a seed to show right into a show-stopping bonsai. Take the next examples beneath. In the event you begin now reasonably than delay, you may be glad you probably did in a couple of years!

How previous do you guess this trident maple is? It may be laborious to consider, however this trident maple – grown from seed by Dan Robinson – is lower than 10 years previous!

How about this Japanese Black Pine? This one was additionally grown on the grounds of Elandan Gardens. It has spent 7 years within the floor to attain substantial trunk dimension which we are able to use as the inspiration of our future design.
Lastly, how previous do you assume this Japanese Black Pine bonsai is? It was additionally grown from seed by Dan Robinson, BUT this tree has spent its whole life in a bonsai pot. At 60-years-old this tree is a testomony to the ability of our talents to form our bonsai by what strategies we use on the outset. Will you develop it in a small bonsai pot, a big coaching pot, or the bottom for any interval? How usually will you prune? These are all decisions it’s important to make based mostly on what kind of tree you need to find yourself with.

3. Subsequent week…

1. Final Week: The Root of All Bonsai

     1A. Seeds
     1B. Cuttings
     1C. Air layers
     1D. City Assortment
     1E. Wild Assortment
2. “Bonsai Seed” Myths

     2A. “Bonsai seed kits are an ideal reward!”
     2B. “Bonsai seeds are uncommon.”
     2C. “All bonsai are grown from seed.”

     2D. “Rising from seed is one of the simplest ways to find out about bonsai.”

     2E. “The extra I prune, the sooner my bonsai will develop.”

     2F. “Rising from seed is a waste of time!”

      3A. Earlier than Germinating
      3B. Getting Began
      3C. 12 months 0 Plan – Watch Them Go!
      3D. 12 months 1 Plan – Prepare the Trunks & Trim the Roots!
      3E. 12 months 2 Plan – Give it extra room!

4. Lengthy-term rising plan
    4A. Floor rising vs pot tradition
    4B. Sacrifice branches
5. Bonus Gallery



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments